Pages

Showing posts with label anti-racism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label anti-racism. Show all posts

Sunday, February 21, 2016

Calling In Phil Anselmo

This is kind of old hat by now, but I wanted to get this post up anyway because it's important. As a blogger who writes about social justice and the metal scene, I don't think I ought to be silent on this, even if I am late to the party. (Or the slaughter, as it may be.)

Anyway, in case you don't listen to metal, or pay even less attention to news than I do, about a month ago Phil Anselmo, former lead vocalist of Pantera, made several racist gestures and comments while performing at Dimebash (the annual event in honor of deceased Pantera guitarist "Dimebag" Darrell Abbott). A fan caught him on video performing a "Sieg Heil" salute and shouting "White power," and he apparently made a comment using the N-word backstage to Robb Flynn of Machine Head. Robb later posted a rambling rant against Phil and racism in metal in general.

While Robb Flynn wasn't the only one in the metal scene taking Phil to task for his racist remarks, I know there's also a portion of the scene going "Who cares, extreme music is supposed to offend," or, "Yeah, that might be racist, but I just like the music, I don't care about the politics." Seeing as that's what so many people say about NSBM (nationalist socialist black metal), misogyny in the metal scene, etc. Because sometimes people with shitty views do make music that sounds really good, and when that bigoted person is on the other side of the world and you're listening to their music on Youtube, it's easy to feel like it doesn't matter.

I've been there. I used to like the music of this one band, probably the most notorious NSBM band, although I didn't know it at the time. When I found out about the neo-Nazi activities of the person behind the band, it took a long time for me to sort out how I felt about it and what to do. A similar thing, but even more intense, happened a while back when I found out that a science fiction and fantasy writer who was one of my faves when I was a teen was giving part of his book profits to anti-LGBT organizations. It took years for me to figure out how I felt about it, but eventually I decided I would never read any of his books again, nor even say his name. It was tough at first, because I had been so moved and inspired by his books, and at first I regretted not being able to continue reading or even recommending his work. But at the same time, I didn't want to give one iota of support, whether in terms of money or publicity, to those sort of views.

Same thing for that one NSBM band, or any other one I might come across, no matter how awesome the music. I decided that I can't separate any act from its social or political impact, and I can't stomach doing anything that would contribute even tangentially to hate or supporting any person who expresses hate in any way.

When I thought of it that way, it helped me to let go of the books I wanted to read and the music I wanted to listen to. I mean, what's more important, being able to enjoy this one band's music, when there are also zillions of other bands out there I could listen to, or the lives of people who will be negatively impacted by the racist and neo-Nazi views and actions the band is encouraging? (Some credit for the phrasing of this thought goes to Metal Chris of DC Heavy Metal, who made the point "there are so many other bands to listen to" in a Facebook discussion about the Phil incident.) Certainly it isn't easy giving up a favorite band, or author, but then again doing the right thing often isn't easy.

But my conscience does rest a lot easier knowing I did the right thing.

So does this mean I will never listen to Pantera again? Well, this story actually has a slightly different ending. For one thing, Pantera was not all Phil, and Rita Haney, Dimebag Darrell's girlfriend, came out condemning Phil's white supremacist actions, while also accepting his apology for the same. Not only that, but later, on February 4 or 5 (judging from tweets of some of the same text) Phil posted another, heartfelt apology, which appears as the splash page of his website:


Since he says, "My band mates are now experiencing the consequences of my behavior," to the point that he has "privately suggested to them that they move on without" him, it seems that, this time the metal community has actually stood up and not made excuses, but has held him accountable for his actions and words at Dimebash, and he is feeling the pressure. Some performances of his current band Down were cancelled even after the new apology, it seems.

And I really want to believe him when he says that "Every citizen in this entire world has the unalienable right to live with dignity and respect without hate or oppression" and "I am utterly responsible for the mistakes I have made, and can only give you my word to no longer do them in the present, through ACTION, not just mere words." I want to believe he really means those things -- not just because I believe in the inherent goodness of people and in giving them a second chance, but because I believe in those things that he said and yearn for other people to believe and work toward them, too.

A couple days ago while working at the library I happened to skim through a book about one of the dogs from Michael Vick's dogfighting ring. At the end of the book was a timeline of the case, what happened to the dogs, and Michael Vick's life afterward. He apparently went bankrupt from being suspended from the NFL and losing his endorsement deals, but then three years later in 2010 he was starting quarterback for the Philadelphia Eagles. My first reaction was, "WTF, they not only let him back in the NFL but gave him a star position, after what he did to those dogs?!" My second thought was, "Well, he did go bankrupt -- is it possible he suffered enough already for what he did, and perhaps ought to have a chance to go on with his life?"

Well, I just looked into it, and it seems like actually, he did not suffer that much -- never served time for animal cruelty, nor expressed any remorse about it, despite the fact that not only did he run a dogfighting ring but brutally tortured and killed the losing dogs.

But anyway, back to Phil Anselmo -- my reaction to the book did lay the groundwork for my reaction to Phil's apology. He has already done more than Michael Vick just by apologizing with such apparent sincerity, and the path is still open for him to atone for his actions. Only time will tell, but the tone of his apology makes me think that this time, maybe he will.

That is why I titled this post "Calling In Phil Anselmo." He has been called out by so many people in the metal scene. He has been sanctioned for what he did. In terms of negative reactions toward his actions, there's not much left to do. It's up to him now to change himself, to make amends, to show he's fit to rejoin the metal scene, a scene that, now in 2016, will no longer tolerate blatant racism from public figures. Because I'm so optimistic about human beings, I hope he will do that and we can invite him back in. (Not that I have any authority to do such a thing. I would guess that POC metal musicians and/or fans would be the most appropriate judges of whether Phil has atoned, although in reality it will probably be some combination of record labels and the media who decide when Phil is "acceptable" again.)

The scene's rising up to speak out against Phil's actions at Dimebash, while awesome to see, was kind of surprising, actually. After all he had been saying stuff like that for decades. But then again, this incident came at a time when race tensions are especially high and the topic is at the forefront of attention in the U.S. It couldn't be worse for him but in a way, it couldn't be better. There couldn't be a better time for us, the metal scene, to practice holding each other accountable, and for us, all of us, including Phil, to work for a more inclusive and equitable scene, and society.

Friday, June 19, 2015

What the Rachel Dolezal Controversy is Teaching Me About Racism

Regarding Rachel Dolezal claiming she is transracial and identifies as black, I feel like I don't have any grounds to say whether or not she can actually be black (seeing as I'm white), and I said my piece about how her situation relates to being transgender in a Facebook post here.

But that's not to say I haven't been doing a lot of thinking about her situation and whether it is actually possible for a human being to cross the divide between black and white. Many voices are saying no - transracial adoptees disputing Ms. Dolezal's use of that word, black women saying that she can't possibly know the struggles of growing up as a black woman, or comprehend the full weight of racist oppression without having lived under it her whole life.

I'm hesitant to disagree with those voices. After all, they know a heck of a lot more about being black and transracial than I do.

And yet, I'm also hesitant to agree, because so much of the criticism leveled at Ms. Dolezal sounds eerily similiar to the criticisms and attitudes hurled at trans women by some feminists and some segments of society - they can't really be women, because they were socialized male and didn't experience the oppression of sexism before transitioning.

Of course, I don't think that the situations of Ms. Dolezal and of transgender women are totally analogous. There are differences. But there are also some similarities, and so I hesitate to throw Ms. Dolezal under the bus for reasons that sound so much like other people's reasons for hating, fearing and hurting transgender women.

My thinking on this is informed by Julia Serano's Whipping Girl, in which she asserts that sexism, the devaluing of women and the reducing of them to sex objects, is at the root of transmisogyny as well as homophobia and society's general derision toward any sort of femininity on the part of those who are assigned male. Again, the situations of Rachel Dolezal and transgender women aren't totally analogous, but it seems pretty clear that racism is a key part of the controversy around Ms. Dolezal. After all, if I, a person of Finnish ancestry, were to claim to be Swedish instead, it would be a lie and might get me in some trouble, but it wouldn't generate nearly the amount of controversy surrounding Ms. Dolezal (at least not in this country, and even in Finland and Sweden, the tensions between people of Finnish and Swedish origin and/or native language aren't nearly as volatile as the tension between black and white here in the U.S.). It is pretty clear that the issue of race, of white privilege and entitlement and of black degradation and suffering, is at the heart of this controversy, and it is the real malady of our society, of which Rachel Dolezal's situation is only a symptom.

And so, instead of talking about Ms. Dolezal over much, I wanted to talk about racism itself. And since I'm on the privileged end of the race issue, and perhaps therefore have less insight than the people who are suffering because of racism, I thought I'd do that by highlighting some keen things written by people of color about racism that I've read thanks to this controversy.

Indeed, if racism didn't exist, then perhaps it wouldn't be such a problem for people to identify as whatever they wish. The thing is, the issue of racism does exist, as pointed out by Syreeta MacFadden in a column in The Guardian:
...to argue that real parity between race and ethnic groups in the United States exists – and can be exchanged one-on-one – is to deny protections for those groups marginalized by institutional power.
She goes on to point out, though, that race and racial identity aren't always clear cut, and that the racial history and racial mixing of this country are as relevant to white people as to black people:
Black America is quite familiar with the complex fluidity of racial and ethnic identity within our families, because we live most directly with the legacy of four centuries of intergenerational chattel slavery in the United States. But while that history of slavery is often positioned by white people and American society as my history, not our history, that is a stupid delineation: the evidence of black or white blood, relationships and rape, flow fairly seamlessly in my bloodline and in white Americans’.
This complexity is perhaps sometimes (often?) invisible to white people, especially to someone like me who is a first generation immigrant from Europe. And yet, if you go way back, I likely have some Central Asian blood in me. Also, no matter where I was born, now that I'm living in this country, the history of slavery should not be ignored, for its effects are still in force today - no matter where I came from, the system of white privilege treats me the same. And the system of racism, the very way we talk about it, ignores that this society in fact holds a continuum, or perhaps more like a cloud, of different skin tones and cultural backgrounds. The institution of racism would have us divide everyone into black and white, when in fact that's not always so clear.

Ms. McFadden quotes Nell Irwin Painter's book The History of White People to make another astute point about racism, which is that it's not so much about black and white, as about black and non-black:
Painter notes that criteria for “race” constantly “shift according to individual taste and political need” and “the fundamental black/white binary endures even though the category of whiteness – or we might say more precisely, a category of nonblackness – effectively expands.” The opposite of whiteness is presumed “alien” or “degenerate”; the opposite of blackness is the presumed moral majority. It is a thinking that denies the value of black people, and limits our acceptance. 
In essence, in U.S. society, black people are considered the ultimate "other," while all other groups are considered more or less part of the norm, the "moral majority," as Ms. McFadden puts it. And such othering, while dehumanizing and unjust, also denies the racial complexity of our society.

I noticed an aspect of that othering in a recent video by vlogger Kat Blaque:
Part of being a black woman in this world is coping with anti-blackness, and the self hate that comes from living in a Euro centric society. Many black women have to go through a journey of self acceptance and love, because they’re taught from day one that their natural features are not beautiful. That is part of the black female experience in this society.
(Note: in that video, Kat Blaque talks a lot about how Rachel Dolezal's situation compares to being transgender. I thought the way she talked about gender was a bit confusing or misleading, though, and that was what led to my post comparing gender and race.)

And then there's this post by Laura Collins Lyster-Mensh on Huffington Post's blog. A person of mixed heritage herself, she argues that the color line, the division between black and white, is "a racist concept based on racial ancestry being some sort of poison to 'white' people you can dilute but not eliminate," and notes that "'White' ancestry does not have the same effect on 'black.'" There is no such thing, she goes on to say, as "really black." "Race doesn't exist, biologically, only as a social construct," she writes, because so, so many of us are of mixed heritage. The insistence on upholding the division between white and black, on classifying anyone with any African blood as black, is a racist tactic to keep black separate from white, and to keep anyone with this "stain" in the black camp. This is because the color line is "one-way," as she puts it - people with any black heritage are allowed to identify as black, but not so for identifying as white. And, Ms. Lyster-Mensh notes, Rachel Dolezal "upsets those who think they should be able to tell the difference by looking. Society wants not only to maintain the color line but to keep one side of it easy to identify."

"There is such a thing as racial identity," Ms. Lyster-Mensh writes, but "it is not genetic. It exists because society thinks there is such a thing as 'black' and 'white' and benefits from those concepts. Post-racism there would be no passing or choosing."

Ms. Lyster-Mensh's description of her own identity resonated with me, not only because some of her statements ring true to my own, different struggles with identity, but because I have a racially mixed daughter, and so I have at times thought about how she will identify when she's older, and whether we are moving toward a post-racial society where many people are a blend. Here is how Ms. Lyster-Mensh describes herself and her own hopes for the future:
How do I self-identify? If asked, as neither. I'm not "black" and I'm not "white." I reject the terms and the identities offered to me. Do people look at me and make assumptions? Yes. I can't help that. I could take the Dolezal route and play up certain hair and lifestyle choices that could push me over the color line, of course; many people of my skin tone do. I could also deliberately "pass" as many mixed people historically have, taking advantage of mainstream racial privilege by denying my family ties. You can say that I'm doing the latter by not deliberately choosing one, considering my appearance, but I actually reserve the right to be myself. I expect the next generation, even more mixed, will too. The color line is fading.
I really love the line, "I reserve the right to be myself." It is something we should all be able to do. I also know from the experience of trying to live as gender non-binary, that it can be difficult when the rest of the world insists on assigning labels to you. We are certainly not at a point, either with regard to race or gender, where living without labels, but just as yourself, is an easy option, and for many people isn't realistic, either.

And I'm not saying that gender differences, or cultural differences between different groups, should be eliminated. The unique things that each person, gender, or culture brings to our world are fabulous and make our world richer. We don't need to all be the same. But to see unjust divisions between groups of people eradicated, to acknowledge that we are all intermingled and interconnected, could only create a better world, and make it safe for all people to be themselves, however that may be.

While there are a lot of practical things we can do to end racism and discrimination, we also need to change our fundamental ways of thinking if we're to uproot this problem once and for all. Controversies like Rachel Dolezal's will only be skin deep, and any results only bandages, unless we open ourselves up to consider the gaping wound of prejudice beneath. We need a bit of the Daoist philosophy of duality and unity, of different parts coming together to make a seamless whole. After all, whether black or white, we are all Americans, and we are all human. At the same time, no matter whether people of the same race, or different, or mixed, we are all different from each other. And we are all beautiful and have something to contribute.

I feel like I'm stating the obvious when I say that the Rachel Dolezal controversy is just the alarm bell; that the real emergency is the pernicious institution of racism that affects all of us. And I am not trying to take away from people who decry Ms. Dolezal's actions as an abuse of privilege, because I sympathize with their outrage and think the discussions they start about race and privilege are very worth having. Yet I also think that the underlying issue bears remembering, because not a one of us but Ms. Dolezal herself can decide how she lives her life; but battling racism, discrimination, and white privilege is something that all of us can do, so that one day, there will be no need for such controversies.

Thursday, April 3, 2014

Being a better anti-racist

Awhile back I found this list of "Common Racist Attitudes and Behaviors (that indicate a wrong turn into white guilt, denial or defensiveness)." Being that I feel more motivated by positive directives rather than being told don't do this and don't do that, I decided to write a list of attitudes and behaviors that an anti-racist should embrace.

That being said, I think it is important to read the original list as well. There are a lot of particular phrases and arguments in there that it would do well to steer clear of. So after checking out that list, here's my list of things I feel one should do to be a better anti-racist. It's long and jumps about a bit and repeats itself slightly - but hopefully there are some nuggets of wisdom in there anyway. Most of these points could be applied to other forms of discrimination and prejudice as well.

Last disclaimer: I didn't know or come up with most of this stuff - I'm just spouting my reflections on the St. Cloud document I linked to above. The real credit goes to them for compiling that very eye-opening list of racist attitudes and behaviors. Here are my thoughts on how to take action on them:

1. Celebrate different appearances and cultures. There is so much richness in the world! There's no need to try and ignore it and make everyone the same. Same is boring!

2. Realize that racism may have played a role in your success and that of others in your family, community, etc. Realize that racism still exists and is still making it harder for people of color to succeed. The playing field is not level. Do what you can to be fair to each individual based on this realization. Fair is not equal. Fair is what's right based on the situation. (Maybe more later on this slogan that I stole from teaching!)

3. Confront your privilege, not people who are pointing it out or reacting to it. It might feel uncomfortable. That's not reverse racism. That's just your conscience. It's ok. It's good that you have one. Now, use that conscience and discomfort to sympathize with people of color and to get energized for acting against racism.

4. Take responsibility. Even if you were not directly responsible for a racist incident, racism as a whole is the fault of white people. (In the US, anyway. In other countries, things may be different, such as Asian countries where one dominant ethnic group is favored over others.) Trying to shift the blame is grossly unfair. Instead, accept the problem and tackle it head on.

5. Work with people of color, not for them. We can only achieve progress against racism through understanding, cooperation and unity. If you're so inclined, get to know people of color and work with them to fight racism. If you're not so inclined...well, it's going to be hard for you to fight racism if you don't actually know any people of color.

6. Listen. If people of color are hurt or offended by something you or others do, it's a sign you should change it and/or oppose it. Even if it was a joke. Why would you want to continue doing something that hurts others??

7. Examine your thoughts and behavior. Especially if you have been called out for doing or saying something racist. Racism is very insidious. I still catch myself making assumptions about people based on race. It could be something automatic you don't even think about, or a way of thinking or perceiving people that you don't even realize is racist. The first step to solving the problem is acknowledging it. To change my thoughts, I adopted the slogan "we're all people" to stop myself from judging others based on skin color (sexual orientation, income level, etc) and remind myself of everyone's basic worth as a human being.

8. Use your own experience to empathize, but not to divert attention. Internally, you can think about the times you faced oppression or hardship in order to create compassion for a person facing racism. Externally, talking about your experience will probably not help, just like if a friend came to you with a problem and you just blabbed about yourself instead of listening to him or her.

9. Educate yourself. There's no excuse for not knowing about the state of the world today. You have news at your fingertips, and if you read it, you will find that sadly, there is very much that is unjust going on in the world. (This is something I need to work on myself - I don't read the news nearly often enough.)

10. Stay focused. There are times when multiple forms of oppression need to be addressed at once, or when you may need to ally with people fighting other forms of discrimination (see #17). But if other forms of oppression are not relevant to the issue at hand, then you should stay focused on the problem of racism, and not bring up other topics.

11. Examine institutions critically. Racism is institutionalized. That's what makes it racism and not just prejudice. Society as a whole has ingrained patterns that discriminate against people of color, and institutions such as law enforcement, schools, media and business reflect these patterns. Question the messages that institutions send.

12. It's not who you know, it's what you do. Just having personal interactions with people of color isn't usually enough to make someone an anti-racist. You have to be willing to question your actions and beliefs, question the way our society works and take action to change things.

13. Do something! It can be scary to confront racism, but imagine how much worse it is for the person experiencing it. Saying sorry afterward is too late - do what you can to stop racism when/before it happens. Better yet, get involved in a larger effort to stop racism altogether.

14. Educate others. Instead of making excuses for your friend or relative who says or does racist things, communicate with that person about why what they're doing is offensive and hurtful. It might take several tries. It might take a lifetime. Nothing's going to change if you don't try.

15. Realize that racism is the default in US society. Everyone has it; it's transmitted to us by our parents, our schools and communities, the media, filling us with assumptions about people we've never met, assumptions that breed misunderstanding, fear, dislike, intolerance and hate, assumptions that are heavily skewed to give power to whites and deny it to people of color. And because everyone has it, it's everyone's problem. You can't avoid it. In order to change things, everyone has to acknowledge the problem and work together for a more just society.

16. Make yourself something to be proud of. You don't need to appropriate someone else's culture to show how enlightened you are. Doing so is actually just another form of oppression. Instead, make yourself and your culture something to be proud of, by showing compassion and understanding for others, refusing to oppress others and working to dismantle the societal patterns that do so. You have the power to give up your power. Don't run away from that decision by pretending to be something you're not!

17. Make anti-racism part of your portfolio. So you're a gay rights activist, or an activist for people with disabilities, or a feminist. That's great! Why not also be an anti-racist? Why stand for any kind of discrimination or oppression? We should take a stand against oppression whenever and wherever we see it - no one of these causes takes precedence over another, and there's no reason why if you stand for one, you can't stand for the others as well.

18. Address the overall problem. Racism is not just individual acts of prejudice, it's a pattern of such acts that forms an institution of oppression against people of color. Individual acts of prejudice are generally signs of that pattern acting itself out in your group, community, organization, etc. To solve the problem and stop further acts of prejudice, you need to address the underlying pattern - racism - and not just the individual acts. (This may take time, of course.)

19. Act naturally. There's no need to treat people of color (or anyone who's different from yourself) with kid gloves. Just be yourself, and be fair.

20. Do your own work. Take the initiative to learn about racism and how to fight it, rather than passively depending on people of color to just call you out when you accidentally act racist. You don't want to just stand by while oppression is going on! There are tons of resources out there to learn about racism (and I'll be posting more on it myself). This site is a good start. http://racism.org/

21. Be understanding toward other white people. You were once in their shoes as some "less knowledgeable" about racism. You may still have racist assumptions that pop up from time to time (I know I do!). Nobody's perfect, and sympathy and gentle correction go a lot further to changing minds than do anger and frustration.

22. Walk the walk. Wimps and poseurs, leave the hall! Just appearing anti-racist is not going to change anything - you need to take decisive action to make a difference.

23. Think big. As some previous points have explained, racism is an institution. Changing your own behavior goes a tiny way toward making change, but significant change can only be effected by tackling the systemic patterns of racism throughout society.

24. Broaden your circle. Make an extra effort to include people of color in your social activities. For me personally, this means making an effort to talk to people of color at metal concerts and goth/industrial clubs, so that they feel welcome. This is necessary because these events are generally dominated by white people, even though metal and goth/industrial culture are for everyone. In the face of this exclusiveness, an extra effort is needed to make people of color feel welcome. (This doesn't mean any special treatment. Just being friendly, so they don't feel left out in a sea of whiteness. "Hey, cool shirt, man," is probably the most I could manage with most people, but who knows, I might make some new friends :) )

25. Give generously. There's no need to keep a tally of how many anti-racist actions you've taken, or to expect anything in return, not even thanks. (See #25) Give freely of your time, energy and material resources without keeping score.

26. Speak up! Standing by while racism happens is colluding with racism. It can be scary to speak up, whether the person you need to speak up to is your friend or your boss, and there may even be times when it actually is better to remain silent for now, and take action later (as mentioned in the St. Cloud document itself). Remind yourself that nothing worth doing is easy, and screw your courage to the sticking place and take a stand.

27. Do it for yourself. Of course fighting racism helps people of color, but expecting their gratitude should not be your motivation for doing so. Find the motivation within yourself - to fight racism because it's the right thing to do, because it will make the world better for everybody - including yourself.

28. Perseverance! This issue's roots stretch back centuries. One challenged remark or blog post or campaign isn't going to solve it. Dig in for the long haul, because we may well be fighting this battle for the rest of our lives. But it's a good fight, and we can do it - through perseverance, against all opposition!